between silence and light

With the invention of new technology, there was a lot of debate about which CRAFT was better: handcrafted or machine-made. Morris thought that “good design could only be produced by men and women working creatively with their hands” (Massey 12). The problem with handcrafted furniture and objects is the high cost involved. Mass production allowed the middle and lower classes to gain access to these goods. “Artistic merit was subordinate to matters of technique; but industrial processes were essential to provide for the increased numbers in the middle classes and their requirements for simple, comfortable, and lightly scaled furniture for apartment living” (Blakemore 350). But sometimes nothing compares to a handmade object. It makes the artifact unique and has a certain level of craft that cannot be achieved otherwise. “The more clearly expressed the construction the more honest the piece, and the greater the contrast with the machine-carved, highly polished veneers of mainstream taste” (Massey 15). I believe this is the reason the teachers in studio stress drawing development so much. Drawing by hand gives a better idea and essence of a room than computer-generated images.



VIRTUAL is a visual representation of something without its physical presence. These visuals allow us to understand a space without having to be there… or even without the space or object even existing at all. As designers, we have to do renderings of rooms that do not yet exist so that clients can visualize the space. Using real furniture and materials adds to the realism. The result is a virtual representation of a non-existent space. The same effect can come from faux finishes. “[Ruskin] warned against the common practice of making one material look like another” (Massey 10). Yet this technique is heavily used. At Monticello, the façade appears to be brick, but it is wood sprayed with sand and made to resemble brick. On our campus, the brick crosswalks often are not brick at all. They are asphalt that is heated then stamped into a brick pattern and texture. The faux finishes or false materials are accurate enough to pass as the real thing.



The only way to achieve the desired effects is through specific TECHNIQUES. In drawing, we have experimented with a variety of mediums, drawing styles, and papers to figure out what works best for each project. One thing we practiced earlier this semester was using one colored pencil to make a drawing interesting. I used the same technique above. Techniques can be carried from one discipline to another. A designer can make a room interesting using neutrals with shades and tints of the same color. The English Free Architecture Movement was all about this idea of creating a uniform language across disciplines. What works in one context can often be used or modified elsewhere. This is the story of the Crystal Palace, designed by horticulturist Joseph Paxton. To build greenhouses, he used modular columns and beams and standardized panels of glass that could be translated into a larger building for the exhibition. The result was the Crystal Palace (Roth 487). “In a few years, the same rapidity in invention and perfection would occur in the development of the high-rise office buildings in the United States” (Roth 489).



LANGUAGES can be a combination of multiple influences, each lending unique qualities. The aesthetic movement had heavy British and Japanese influences. “Soon afterwards [Arthur Liberty] opened Liberty’s, the shop that went on to establish the exclusive ‘Liberty & Co.’ look, supplying oriental ceramics and textiles with British-designed metalwork and furniture for the creation of fashionable interiors” (Massey 26). Looking at Monticello, it is interesting to see how the French culture has influenced his work. After he came back from France, he designed Monticello II, which included distinct parquet flooring, elliptical arches, and other additions. The merge of the French and American styles gave the house a new language that made it a standout building. We borrow often from contemporary styles, but just as often from previous styles. We bring old languages and styles from silence into light by emphasizing them in new ways. “The alternative was a new approach to building design in which historically- derived details were inventively manipulated in buildings planned strictly in accord with contemporary functional requirements” (Roth 482). Bringing together a variety of elements can give architecture new life and bring it into the forefront.



As royalty accumulates grand collections of exotic artifacts and designers create innovative masterpieces, they naturally want to move these items from PRIVATE to PUBLIC. “Enlightened European monarchs and princes had been opening their residences to the public so that their collections of painting and sculpture could be viewed and studied” (Roth 473). This is the reason Glyptothek (the Sculpture Museum) and the Altes Museum in Germany were built. These great, exotic collections were moved from silence into light so that others could admire and learn from them. The same events occurred at Monticello and Falling Water. These once private residences became icons in American history and needed to be shared with the world. The only problem with opening up these spaces to the public is that a lot of the original furniture and items in the houses had to be removed to make way for tourists to circulate. At both of these sites, I found myself wishing I could see these places as a visitor to the families, rather than as a tourist. With all of the original pieces still in place, I would have gotten a more complete essence of the buildings.

This week was about ways we transition styles, artifacts, and spaces from privacy or darkness into a more glorified light. There are so many great moments in architecture throughout the world that are not well-known because no one has shed light on them. The same can be said about nature. It is mind-blowing to think about the intricacy of nature and all the things we do not know about it. It is also exciting to think about all the new things we will discover about both architecture and nature in the future.


Blakemore, Robbie G. (1997). History of Interior Design & Furniture. New York, NY: Van Nostrand Reinhold

Massey, Anne. (1990). Interior Design of the 20th Century. London: Thames & Hudson

Roth, Leland M. (2007). Understanding Architecture: Its Elements, History, and Meaning. Boulder, CO: Westview Press